Weiter zum Inhalt

Reconstructing Weber’s Indian Rationalism: A Comparative Analysis

DOI https://doi.org/10.15543/MWS/2017/2/7

Stephen Kalberg

Max Weber’s Religion of India (RI) fails to offer his full analysis of the origins and contours of the ‘rationalism’ of India. Instead, a synthesis of this work with innumerable passages on India in, primarily, his Economy and Society and General Economic History volumes is required. When fully reconstructed in this manner, seven elements can be seen to be central to Indian rationalism. This article defines these elements through, following Weber, regular comparisons to ‘Western rationalism’ and ‘Chinese rationalism’. Doing so leads to an unorthodox conclusion: Weber’s rationalism of India construct constitutes not simply a ‘contrast case’ that serves to demarcate Western rationalism, as frequently argued; rather, it also delineates the uniqueness of India. This reconstruction further provides Weber’s more complete analysis of the origin and expansion of the many obstacles in India to the rationalization of action in the law, rulership, and economy spheres. Contrasts to the trajectory taken in the West toward modern capitalism are emphasized.

1 Adluri, V.P. 2011. ‘Pride and Prejudice: Orientalism and German Indology’. International Journal of Hindu Studies 15(3): 253-92. [Crossref]

2 Ahmed, M. 2016. ‘Why Hindutva Groups have for long had Sheldon Pollock in their Sights’, https://tinyurl.com/804517-pollock (accessed 30/8/16).

3 Anderson, P. 1974. Lineages of the Absolute State. London: Verso.

4 Bronner, Y. 2011. ‘A Text with a Thesis: The Ramayana from Appayya Diksita’s Receptive End’, in South Asian Texts in History: Critical Engagements with Sheldon Pollock, edited by Y. Bronner, W. Cox and L. McCrea. Ann Arbor: Association for Asian Studies: 45-63.

5 Bronner, Y., and D. Shulman 2006. ‘A Cloud Turned Goose: Sanskrit in the Vernacular Millennium’. Indian Economic and Social History Review 43: 1-30. [Crossref]

6 Bronner, Y., W. Cox and L. McCrea 2011. ‘Introduction’, in South Asian Texts in History: Critical Engagements with Sheldon Pollock, edited by Y. Bronner, W. Cox and L. McCrea. Ann Arbor: Association for Asian Studies: 1-22.

7 Brubaker, R. 1984. The Limits of Rationality: An Essay on the Social and Moral Thought of Max Weber. London: Allen & Unwin.

8 Burghart, R. 1996. ‘A Quarrel in the Language Family: Agency and Representations of Speech in Mithila’, Ch. 14 in his The Conditions of Listening: Essays on Religion, History and Politics in South Asia. Delhi: Oxford University Press.

9 Chaudhuri, K.N. 1990. Asia Before Europe: Economy and Civilisation of the Indian Ocean from the Rise of Islam to 1750. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

10 Davidson, R.M. 2002. Indian Esoteric Buddhism: A Social History of the Tantric Movement. New York: Columbia University Press.

11 Eisenstadt, S.N. 2000. ‘Multiple Modernities’. Daedalus 129: 1-29. [Crossref]

12 Elias, N. 1994. The Civilizing Process. Oxford: Blackwell.

13 Fox, R.G. (ed.) 1977. Realm and Region in Traditional India. Durham, MC: Duke University Press.

14 Gellner, D.N. 2001. The Anthropology of Buddhism and Hinduism: Weberian Themes. Delhi: Oxford University Press.

15 Gellner, D.N. 2009. ‘The Uses of Max Weber: Legitimation and Amnesia in Buddhology, South Asian History, and Anthropological Practice Theory’, in The Oxford Handbook of the Sociology of Religion, edited by P. Clarke. Oxford University Press: 48-62. [Crossref]

16 Gellner, D.N. 2016. ‘The Idea of Nepal’ (Mahesh Chandra Regmi Lecture 2016), http://soscbaha.org/downloads/mcrl2016.pdf

17 Gorski, P.S. 2003. The Disciplinary Revolution: Calvinism and the Rise of the State in Early Modern Europe. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press. [Crossref]

18 Grünendahl, R. 2012. ‘History in the Making: On Sheldon Pollock’s “NS Indology” and Vishwa Adluri’s “Pride and Prejudice”’. International Journal of Hindu Studies 16(2): 189-257. [Crossref]

19 Gupta, S., and R.F. Gombrich. 1986. ‘Kings, Power, and the Goddess’. South Asia Research 6: 123-38. [Crossref]

20 Hastings, A. 1997. The Construction of Nationhood: Ethnicity, Religion and Nationalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

21 Kalberg, S. 2012. Max Weber’s Comparative-Historical Sociology Today. Farnham: Ashgate.

22 Kantowsky, D. 1986a (ed.) Recent Research on Max Weber’s Studies of Hinduism. Munich: Weltforum Verlag.

23 Kantowsky, D. 1986b. ‘The Misinterpretation of Max Weber’s Study on Hinduism in India: Causes and Consequences’, in Kantowsky 1986a: 209-23.

24 Kornicki, P. 2008. ‘The Latin of East Asia?’ (Sanders Lectures in Bibliography 2008), www.lib.cam.ac.uk/kornicki1.pdf

25 Kulke, H. (ed.) 1995. The State in India: 1000–1700. Delhi: Oxford University Press.

26 Malhotra, R. 2016. The Battle for Sanskrit: Is Sanskrit Political or Sacred? Oppressive or Liberating? Dead or Alive? Delhi: Harper Collins.

27 McCrea, L. 2013. ‘Thoughts on Sheldon Pollock’s The Language of the Gods in the World of Men’. Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and the Middle East 33(1): 117-24. [Crossref]

28 Michaels, A. 1997. ‘The King and the Cow: On a Crucial Symbol of Hinduization in Nepal’, in Nationalism and Ethnicity in a Hindu Kingdom, edited by D.N. Gellner, J. Pfaff-Czarnecka and J. Whelpton. Amsterdam: Harwood: 79-99.

29 Mitchell, L. 2009. Language, Emotion, and Politics in South India: The Making of a Mother Tongue. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

30 Mocko, A.T. 2016. Demoting Vishnu: Ritual, Politics, and the Unraveling of Nepal’s Hindu Monarchy. New York: Oxford University Press. [Crossref]

31 Pollock, S. 1993a. ‘Ramaya?a and Political Imagination in India’. Journal of Asian Studies 52(2): 261-97.

32 Pollock, S. 1993b. ‘Deep Orientalism? Notes on Sanskrit and Power Beyond the Raj’, in Orientalism and the Postcolonial Predicament: Perspectives on South Asia, edited by C.A. Breckenridge and P. van der Veer. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press: 76-133.

33 Pollock, S. 2006. The Language of the Gods in the World of Men: Sanskrit, Culture, and Power in Premodern India. Berkeley: University of California Press.

34 Pollock, S. 2008. ‘Towards a Political Philology: D.D. Kosambi and Sanskrit’, in Forms of Knowledge in Early Modern Asia: Explorations in the Intellectual History of India and Tibet, 1500–1800, edited by S. Pollock. Durham, NC: Duke University Press: 1-16.

35 Pollock, S. 2014. ‘What is South Asian Knowledge Good For?’, South Asia Institute Papers (Heidelberg) 1, www.sai.uni-heidelberg.de

36 Rao, V.N., D. Shulman and S. Subrahmanyam. 2007. ‘A Pragmatic Response’. History and Theory 46: 409-27. [Crossref]

37 Samuel, G. 2008. The Origins of Yoga and Tantra: Indic Religion to the Thirteenth Century. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Crossref]

38 Schopen, G. 1997. Bones, Stones, and Buddhist Monks: Collected Papers on the Archaeology, Epigraphy, and Texts of Monastic Buddhism in India. Honolulu: Hawaii University Press.

39 Schluchter, W. 1981. The Rise of Western Rationalism, translated by G. Roth. Berkeley: University of California Press.

40 Shrestha, Hariman 2009. Katti Pyakhan. Lalitpur: Jyesth Nagarik Samaj.

41 Shulman, D. 2007. ‘Review Essay [on Pollock 2006]’. Journal of Asian Studies 66(3): 819-25. [Crossref]

42 Smith, A.D. 1986. The Ethnic Origins of Nations. Oxford: Blackwell.

43 Taylor, M. 2011. ‘Mythology Wars: The Indian Diaspora, “Wendy’s Children” and the Struggle for the Hindu Past’. Asian Studies Review 35(2): 149-68. [Crossref]

44 Tambiah, S.J. 1976. World Conqueror and World Renouncer. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Crossref]

45 Toffin, G. 1993. Le palais et le temple: La function royale dans la vallée du Népal. Paris: CNRS.

46 Toffin, G. 2007. Newar Society: City, Village and Periphery. Lalitpur: Himal Books for Social Science Baha.

47 Toffin, G. 2010. La fête-spectacle: Théâtre et rite au Népal. Paris: Editions de la Maison des Sciences de l’Homme. [Crossref]

48 Tribe, K. 1989. ‘Introduction’, in Reading Weber, edited by K. Tribe. London: Routledge: 1-14.

49 Witzel, M. 1987. ‘The Coronation Rituals of Nepal, with special reference to the Coronation of King Birendra (1975)’, in Heritage of the Kathmandu Valley, edited by N. Gutschow and A. Michaels. Sankt Augustin: VGH Wissenschaftsverlag: 415-67.

50 Wujastyk, D. 2016. ‘Against the Petition Against Prof. Pollock’, http://list.indology.info/pipermail/indology_list.indology.info/2016-February/042835.html (accessed 30/8/16).

51 Zotter, A. 2016. ‘State Rituals in a Secular State? Replacing the Nepalese King in the Pacali Bhairava Sword Procession and other Rituals’, in Religion, Secularism, and Ethnicity in Contemporary Nepal, edited by D.N. Gellner, S.L Hausner and C. Letizia. Delhi: Oxford University Press: 265-301.


Export Citation